As a rather nerdy individual, word games should be right up my alley, right? Wrong! I don’t like word games. I find them boring, stupid, and lacking in creativity. Some are better than others; scrabble is considered a classic word game, beloved by all. (I still think it sucks. It sucks a little less than some other words games though.)

Codenames is a vastly popular game, loved by many, but not by me. Similar to Sushi Go!, there is nothing inherently wrong with Codenames. Also similar to Sushi Go!, the replayability on Codenames is seriously lacking.
It is a simple game, easy to learn, and great for parties; so what is there to not like? Unfortunately, so much!
In Codenames, you place twenty five double-sided cards in a 5×5 grid and give one word clues to get your teammates to guess multiple cards. For example, in the grid below I might give the clue: “places, five.” The “five” tells my teammates how many cards that clue relates to. With luck, they would guess: Europe, Bermuda, Jupiter, Germany, and Washington. However, they might guess ‘forest’ or ‘alps,’ immediately ending the turn on an incorrect guess.

Giving clues isn’t quite that simple though. Players are divided into two teams, each with their own set of cards to guess.

The image to the right represents the 5×5 grid of cards, and shows the blue and red clue-givers what cards they need to get their teammates to guess. The black box is the “no-no” card, as I call it. If that card is guessed, the other team immediately wins.
The theme is also kinda stupid in my opinion. The creators have tried to make it fun by adding a spy theme to the game, but it doesn’t make sense for a word game and it detracts from a game that was already quite lacking.
What’s the redeeming value? Personally, nothing. Publicly, I have no idea, but people seem to love it.
Lets now look at the pros and cons of this bland game.

Pros: What pros even are there?
Easy to learn: Codenames is extremely easy to learn. Someone can walk over mid-game and join in with basically no explanation.
Entertaining word game: As far as word games go, Codenames is better than most. It doesn’t feel like an educational game, and is a nice change from the standard taboo-like or spelling games.
Party Game: This game, though it works best with 6 or 8 people, is quite versatile when it comes to number of players. It is great to whip out at a party, and is rather popular. (Don’t ask me why it’a popular, I don’t get the appeal.)
Great for travel: Codenames is in a smaller box than most board games. Codnames will fit into most backpacks as long as the bag isn’t super full. I guess that’s good?

Cons: Boy are there a lot of them this time.
Too easy: Like Sushi GO! (which you should totally read my review of if you haven’t already), Codenames is too simple to keep one entertained for a long time.
It’s a word game: Let’s be honest, most word games are trash, plain and simple. Codenames is a word game. I think you know my opinion.
Party Game: Party games are often lacking in creativity, depth, or complexity. This is so that the game won’t take a while to explain, and the group can just jump right in to the game play. That is a benefit of a party game like Codenames, but that also means that it lacks creativity, depth, and complexity.
Boring Art: Let me be frank: this art is mediocre at best. It is rather bland and lacking. While is isn’t bad, so to speak, there is no redeeming value to it’s simplicity.
Lacks replayability: While the game contains over a hundred double-sided cards, which seems like it would add great replayability, the gameplay itself never changes, so each game is basically the same.
Weird Theme: The spy theme has absolutely nothing to do with the gameplay. I understand that games nowadays need a theme, but why on earth would you chose spies for a word game? It makes no sense and has no relevance to the game.
Let’s now score this game. Five categories: artwork, gameplay, replayability, my opinion, and public consensus (ratings found on Amazon.) Each are scored on a scale of ten and then added together.
Artwork: 3/10
Gameplay: 5/10
Replayability: 4/10
My opinion: 3/10
Public Consensus: 10/10

25/50, or 5/10. Not too bad of a score for a word game, but still, not a great game.
Overall, I think Codenames should stay on the shelf during board game night. It’s not worth it.
Let me know your thoughts in the comments below. Do you agree with me? Why/why not? Are you no longer wanting to buy Codenames because of this post? Don’t forget to like and subscribe for more obnoxiously blatant opinions!
If you want to see a fantastic YouTuber explain how to play Codenames, go check out my man Rodney over at Watch it Played! Here’s a link to the video – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8RWBooJivg
Happy gaming to you all!






















